For Your Controversial Information

Clergy Corner by Fr. Robert Falabella for July 19, 2015

Clergy Corner by Fr. Robert Falabella for July 19, 2015

__________________________________________________________________________

Recently, Mike Gallagher, WGTK Conservative Talk Show Host, interviewed Bill Donohue, President of the Catholic League -- the Nation’s largest Catholic Civil Rights Group -- concerning the Encyclical of Pope Francis on Global Warming. Herein was the discussion:

Gallagher: The syndicated Journalist, Dr. Charles Krauthammer criticized the Pope on his (Pope Francis’) position on Global Warming, saying (sardonically): “I was not aware the Pope was a scientist…” (Krauthammer then continued) “…on ethics and dogma, we respect that, but the minute he (the Pope) steps outside of that and acts as a scientist or politician, he opens himself up to criticism that is given to anyone else.”

Gallagher: “Bill Donohue, was Charles Krauthammer right?”

Donohue: “Half right; Krauthammer is wrong when saying the Pope must strictly stick to only Faith and Morals -- for there is a moral dimension to environmental destruction -- they (popes) talk about how, (since) we are God’s Stewards, we have to take control of the earth (Confer Genesis 1:26;28)… Now where I would agree with Krauthammer is this: When the Pope gets “MICRO” and starts giving way to sweeping general statements about “HOW” we must specifically deal with the environment through controversial theories, when there are equally strong counter proposals; when the Pope gets into such things, for instance, (as) having a real problem with air conditioning -- (which he does…it is in the document #155) …and when he says carbon dioxide is a pollutant -- well, carbon dioxide is not something that has been added by humans -- it is constitutive of being a human being; so when you say those kind of things -- when you get into the ‘Weave’ and get very “Micro” that’s why peoples’ eyes will roll and they will say: ‘Wait a minute, where does the Pope have the authority to be that specific as to how we should do it? -- especially when the “how” has nothing to do with God’s Revealed Word! There Iies also a very much anti-market force animus here -- most of the document is blaming Capitalism virtually for any problem we have.”

 

Donohue continues: “Now the Liberals are not going to like some parts of the Encyclical when (Pope Francis) talks about how he is against “Population Control;” …he is against Abortion; he emphasizes the natural differences between men and women; he does not cancel them out -- he has a number of things to say about that.”

Donohue continues: “I think it is unfortunate that the document does not have better editors. Let me be very specific: At Paragraph # 61, the Pope asks us to reject doomsday predictions on the catastrophic effects that will befall the world due to especially carbon emissions. I’m glad he said that since, up to that point, he seems to have a lot of doomsday predictions. But when you jump to paragraph # 161 -- Pope Francis writes: (I quote)… “Doomsday predictions no longer are to be met with irony or disdain…” So which one is it, #61 or #161?”

Gallagher interjects: “And Bill, let’s face it, this is not the first time there has been some controversy over a position the Church has taken. There are always risks … don’t forget the US Catholic Bishops in the early “Eighties” opposed Nuclear Deterrence -- they called that “immoral.” But as Krauthammer points out: “That kept us safe and avoided war for fifty years.”

Donohue: “That’s why good motives can get you into A LOT OF TROUBLE. (Recall) The Bishops were also against the 1996 Welfare Reform Act that Clinton had to sign, which would liberate the ‘poor’ from the state of dependency and from everything else. (And so) While Patrick Moynihan was a champion of the ‘poor;’ and the Bishops were champions of the ‘poor,’ they were both wrong because in 1966 both were opposed to the Welfare Reform Act. So good intentions can only get you so far.”

Donohue: “Let me say a final thing -- Pope Benedict the XVI, when he was Cardinal Ratzinger, in the year 2004, said it is entirely possible to be a good Catholic and disagree with the Church’s teachings on such things that are not    DOCTRINALLY DEFINED BY THE CHURCH, as when it is right to wage war or acceptance of the Death Penalty.”

Fr. Robert’s Comment: Such has to do with the moral difference between “killing” and “murder.” Every murder will always involve an immoral killing; but every moral killing does not involve murder. Further, the Code of Canon Law, # 749, #3 states: “No doctrine is understood to be infallible defined unless it is …clearly and firmly shown to have been authentically proposed in that manner. In fact, the exercise of the infallible teaching authority is extremely rare” (page 57).

Donohue continues: “But you cannot disagree on things like Abortion or Euthanasia which have to do with “murder” -- in other words, there is a hierarchy here -- so this statement on climate change or global warming should be given respect, but Catholics are not required to give full assent.”

Father Robert’s comment: For instance we Catholics are required to give assent EVEN to those teachings of the Church on Apparitions or accepted Devotions which are permitted by the Church, but not requirements as such. Thus, if a Catholic does not find spiritual enrichment and a fostering of a deeper love and faith in Jesus Christ, one is not required to embrace it; (and one is not less “Catholic” for having this position; while for others such teachings may be found to enrich their faith, and so the Church embraces them as well.

Ever in the love of Christ,

Father Robert

Tags: homily, clergy corner
 

Clergy Corner

Read our Clergy Corner blog.


Recent

When in Doubt…

Friday, February 14, 2020
Unfortunately, when I hear this phrase, I still think of the old rule in school, “when in doubt, Charlie out.” As in, if you... Read More

The Beatitudes

Saturday, February 1, 2020
So what is now the significance of Jesus’ beatitudes and why are they so central to his teaching? The beatitudes respond to the natural... Read More

The Word Made Flesh

Saturday, January 25, 2020
The Word Made Flesh Recently the focus as we moved through Christmas was on the “made flesh” part of this title, but I want to take... Read More

Epiphany

Saturday, January 4, 2020
Today’s epiphany is not only God’s   revelation of Himself; it is also the manifestation of who we really are without God. We... Read More

The Final Push … and then Rejoice!

Saturday, December 21, 2019
Whereas this title could make you think of all kinds of things, I just want to  remind you to buckle in spiritually for the last couple of... Read More

The Feast of the Immaculate Conception

Friday, December 6, 2019
The feast of the Immaculate Conception of Mary reminds me of the chalice because in a way, when Mary was carrying Jesus in her womb, she was a... Read More

Alpha and Omega in the Holy Land

Thursday, November 21, 2019
This weekend we celebrate the last Sunday of the Liturgical year in the  Solemnity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, King of the Universe. Christ who... Read More

Overcoming Death

Friday, November 8, 2019
We Christians have a strong faith in life after  death. In fact, eternal life to a Christian does not begin with death, it begins with this... Read More

What are you willing to die for?

Friday, October 25, 2019
Recently, Archbishop Chaput of Philadelphia spoke to a group of students at Notre Dame and asked them to contemplate what is it that they are... Read More

Increase Our Faith

Saturday, October 12, 2019
We believe that small things have an impact on big things. For example, one misses the train and a chain reaction occurs in which one is late to... Read More

The Greatest Showman

Friday, September 27, 2019
I always tell people that every movie, every song, no matter the setting, has a lesson that can be pulled out. The thing is that that lesson might... Read More

Happy Birthday, Blessed Mother!

Sunday, September 8, 2019
We celebrate her birth in a very special way because she gave birth to the Son of God. The Blessed Virgin Mary’s significance to us is... Read More

Past, Present and Future

Saturday, August 31, 2019
Most of us are familiar with the phrase, “Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.” It makes sense to look at human... Read More

​​​​​​​The True Treasures of the Church

Friday, August 2, 2019
In the year 258AD, Emperor Valerian restarted the persecution against the Christians calling for the execution of every bishop, priest and deacon,... Read More

A New Day will Begin!

Friday, July 19, 2019
In the song, entitled Memory, it says, “Daylight, I must wait for the sunrise, I must think of a new life.  And I mustn’t give in.... Read More

Online Giving

Online Giving

Secure and Convenient Donate now!